Battery Issues

 

Battery Charger & Separator

What you think you have might not be what you actually have. That's what a friend of mine told me when discussing the setup in my boat...and he was right.

The Camano was built with a Battery Separator. Instead of a mechanical battery switch, the separator is tied to the engine battery and the house battery bank. 

The unit does 2 things. 1. Assist in engine starting: When the engine starter is activated, the separator compares the voltage of both battery banks. If the start/engine battery is lower than the house battery bank, the Battery Separator will engage allowing the house battery to "aid" in starting. 2. Protect the starting system: The Battery Separator monitors the battery system to determine if the batteries are being charged. When the engine or house batteries reach 13-13.5 volts, indicating that charging is taking place, the Battery Separator will engage, joining the two battery banks. If the drain on the charging system by either battery bank reduces the system voltage below 12.4-12.9 volts, the Battery Separator will disconnect the battery banks from each other, protecting each bank from excessive drain.

...that is what is supposed to happen. Not until placing a voltage meter on each battery did I realize that although my engine battery was charging from the engine alternator, the house bank was not! There is a red indicator light on the battery separator which would come on indicating it was indeed working. It was not. When Pau Hana was in the marina and on shore power, the battery charger itself worked to keep the batteries topped off and when out on the water my solar panels kept the house banks charged, so I had no idea there was a problem.

Top of Battery Separator

I did two things. First I wanted a way to "at a glance", monitor the battery banks. The existing analog volt meter worked fine but I needed to bend down and operate the switch to show the charge on the analog meter of either bank. I decided to remove the analog volt meter and the switch and install multiple meters that would be easy to view constantly. I located a LED dual voltage meter.

 I made a panel that fit over both the analog meter and the switch hole. I added some voltage baselines to give me an idea of the current state of the batteries and not allow the batteries to fall to a damage level.

To start, I turned off the solar panels, disconnected all of the positive battery terminals, and turned off the battery charger and with a multimeter, tested to ensure I had no voltage coming in.

The installation was pretty straight forward. Remove the switch, lengthen the wires some and install the connectors for the new dual voltmeter. The 2 top screw holes of the new panel lined up with the top holes of the old analog meter. That meant using the 2 bottom holes of the new panel as a guide to drill the bottom screws.

Next I replaced the battery separator. This installation was also straight forward. I labeled each positive battery line to be sure I connected them properly.


 I reconnected all the battery terminals and the new dual meter indicated the voltage at both battery banks. Next I started the engine and I could see that as the key was turned, the voltage on the engine battery dropped, then immediately started to increase, then I could see that the house bank voltage was increasing as well. 

The Meter shows the Batteries "Bulk" Charging

This new meter is excellent. On our recent boating trip we anchored out for the evening and I could constantly monitor my battery banks. Even as the house bank lowered, I could see the starting battery was full and ready to go.

UPDATE: 8/20/22

The new meter is awesome and came in handy just a couple of weeks after the installation. 
We spent the weekend on the boat when I noticed the House Battery bank going down, down even though the battery charger was turned on. I did some troubleshooting on the battery charger. It was DOA. After 22 years it had had enough. I was able to locate a new 20 Amp 3 bank charger at West Marine. It was a pretty easy install and was smaller, all solid state and probably much more efficient than the old one. It has a much nicer read out showing the state the charge is in and the level of the battery charge.

Mastervolt Battery Charger

Had I not had my new meters I wouldn't have know there was a problem until perhaps it was too late. 






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Bottom Line

Image
    H ere in the Crystal River area where we keep our boat, underwater fouling is minimal. This is due to the amount of fresh water we have. Our canal is "brackish" with not alot of salinity and the closer you are to King's Bay and the springs the salinity goes way down. Out to the Gulf and further south, hull bottom fouling becomes worse. Go to the Keys and the Bahamas and it is very aggressive.  Wintertime when the water is cold, the growth is minimal, but when the water warms it is alive with billions of tiny organisms ready to cling to something and start reproducing. Now that our boat is in Tampa Bay and the water temperature is moving into the 70's the growth is accelerating.  How do we combat this? The list of ways is endless but the basic method is to apply Anti-Fouling coatings. Bottom paint. There is a whole science and tons of info about anti-fouling coatings so I won't go into all of it but basically there are 2 types of paint. Hard & Ablative. Bot...
Read more

Pre Loop Madness and Monotony

Image
   The build up was huge, the anticipation was killing us. Now we're here, living on the boat in Bradenton, FL for the next 14 days before we "shove off". With everything we think we will need for the trip in the back of our car, we load it onto the boat. Where in the heck are we going to put all of this stuff? Organizing and storing in every nook & cranny, sorting and reprioritizing. Re-looking at something and saying, "Do we really need 3 of these?" "Put it back in the car." After two full days, Beth managed to get it all labeled and packed away, somewhere. This little boat has a lot more storage space than we thought. Now, to be able to find it when we want it. I looked for my work gloves for 20 minutes!  "Where is all this stuff going to fit?"     Meanwhile I'm doing the same for all of my tools and gear, gallons of oil, fluids and filters, spare parts and odd things that we just might need to get us out of a pinch.  A few last mi...
Read more

The "REAL" Journey Begins

Image
TRAVEL DAY 1 - Palmetto to Sarasota February 14, 2023 4.2 Hours/31.6 Miles     Today is "really" the day we start of the Great Loop, as opposed to the "Unofficial Start of the Great Loop" . We felt pretty confident that all the preparation and work would pay off . Well, feelings are one thing, realty is another.     We pulled out of our slip and headed for the fuel dock to top off the tanks with a few gallons of diesel and pump out the holding tank. Of course the predicted wind was not what we got, neither was the air temperature, still it was a decent day for a cruise. We're still in our home waters so we basically knew the way. Our destination was Sarasota and a free anchorage. We had planned to pick up an anchor ball at Marina Jack's but it was full. Free anchorages mean more money for food, snacks and drinks! Out of the Manatee River and around Ana Marie Island     Beth had planned some routes on her Navionics and Aqua Maps apps and was ready to assume ...
Read more